Netflix has officially dropped the first trailer for its hghly anticipated biopic about legendary singer-songwriter Barry Manilow—and fans are already buzzing. But the biggest headline of the day? The role of the beloved music icon will be played by none other than Academy Award nominee Timothée Chalamet.
Directed by acclaimed filmmaker Sofia Alvarez, Could It Be Magic aims to go beyond the typical greatest-hits narrative. The film promises to explore Manilow’s inner world—his songwriting genius, personal struggles, showbiz triumphs, and the enduring legacy of a career that has touched millions across generations.
“Barry isn’t just a performer,” Chalamet said in a statement shared alongside the trailer release. “He’s a storyteller, a dreamer, a voice for hope. Embodying him is one of the most moving challenges of my career.”
Known for his deep emotional range and intense preparation, Chalamet reportedly spent months studying Manilow’s performances, working with vocal coaches, and even collaborating with Barry himself to capture the spirit behind his music.
The trailer offers a glimpse into Manilow’s world—flashes of packed concert halls, lonely hotel rooms, and the electric atmosphere of 1970s New York. A stirring remix of “Mandy” plays in the background as Chalamet channels Manilow’s bittersweet charisma.
Fans reacted instantly across social media, many praising the casting decision. “He’s got the heart,” one fan tweeted. “Barry’s music was pure emotion—if anyone can tap into that vulnerability, it’s Timothée.” Some drew comparisons to earlier portrayals of musical legends, but noted that Chalamet’s take feels especially heartfelt and grounded.
Netflix has kept the rest of the cast under wraps for now, though insiders say the film will feature portrayals of key figures in Manilow’s life—from his longtime collaborator Bruce Sussman to important moments behind hits like “Copacabana” and “I Write the Songs.”
Director Sofia Alvarez said the project had been in development for nearly four years. “We didn’t want to make just another musical biopic,” she shared during a virtual press event. “This is Barry’s journey from Brooklyn kid to international sensation—the dreams, the fears, the costs of chasing something bigger than yourself. Timothée brought a sensitivity and authenticity that blew us away.”
Chalamet’s transformation isn’t just skin-deep—although early footage shows him in Manilow’s classic style: tailored suits, dramatic stage lighting, and that unmistakable spark. He reportedly sings many of the songs himself, including “Weekend in New England” and “Can’t Smile Without You,” capturing both the lush romanticism and the emotional honesty that define Manilow’s music.
Set to release globally this fall, Could It Be Magic is already being positioned as a major awards contender. With its blend of emotional depth, dazzling music, and a lead actor at the height of his craft, the film could introduce a new generation to the soul and spirit of Barry Manilow—not just as a pop icon, but as a man who poured his heart into every note.
Whether you’ve been a “Fanilow” for decades or are just discovering his timeless voice, this is one film you won’t want to miss. As Chalamet himself put it, “To play Barry isn’t to imitate him—it’s to understand the heart behind the music.”
